VS 1893 – 1906  ·  AH 1252 – 1266  ·  AD 1836 – 1850  ·  Original Scholarship

Marks on the Mint

Reading the obverse symbols of the Amritsar rupee, from the last years of Ranjit Singh to the annexation

I  ·  The Question

Small Marks, Large Years

The Amritsar Nanakshahi rupee carried the same couplet from Ranjit Singh's coronation to the end of the Sikh state. What changed, year by year, was a small mark set into the obverse field. In the last years of Ranjit Singh's life and in the decade after his death, that mark moved through a run that is hard to read as accident: Ram in Devnagri, Om, a trident, a royal canopy (chattra), a flag beneath the canopy, the Gurmukhi word Sat beneath the canopy, and finally Ram in Lande script and Shiv. In VS 1902 one subtype of the flag issue also carries a rose (gulab) on the reverse.

These were the years in which power at Lahore passed through more hands than in the forty years before: Kharak Singh, Nau Nihal Singh, Chand Kaur, Sher Singh, the child Duleep Singh, four wazirs, the army's panchayats, a British Resident and a Council of Regency. This essay asks whether the marks on the Amritsar rupee record that passage of power — and how far that can honestly be claimed.

No document yet found says who chose these marks, or why. Hans Herrli, whose tables of the Amritsar marks remain the standard record, concluded that "the true marks are probably related to the control of the coinage, the administration of the mint and the coin production, but the exact meaning of the different marks still remains entirely unknown." What follows is therefore an argument from coincidence of date, symbol and person. Each reading is graded on the scale used throughout this site:

Documented a contemporary record states it Argued the dates and the symbol fit a named person or office, and no simpler reading fits as well Open a reading is possible, but an equally simple one fits

No reading on this page reaches the first grade.

II  ·  Chronology

Three Eras and Three New Years

Every argument on this page depends on matching a Vikrami year to events, and the Vikrami year did not begin on 1 January. Three reckonings were current in the Punjab of the 1840s:

The lunar year from Chaitra (Chaitradi). It begins on the first day of the bright fortnight of Chaitra, between mid-March and mid-April.

The lunar year from Kartik (Kartikadi). It begins on the day after Diwali, between mid-October and mid-November — up to seven months after the Chaitra new year, so the same VS number falls up to seven months later.

The solar year from Vaisakh. Civil dates in the Punjab were written in solar months — Vaisakh, Jeth, Harh, Sawan, Bhadon, Assu, Katak, Maghar, Poh, Magh, Phagan, Chet — whose first day falls at the sun's entry into each sign. Its year turns at Vaisakhi, on 12 or 13 April in these years, close to the Chaitra reckoning. Ranjit Singh's death on 27 June 1839 is recorded as 15 Harh 1896; the calculation used for this page gives the same day, which confirms the method.

This essay takes the Kartik reckoning as its working convention for the coin years, which is the author's reading of the Lahore-period mint year. The marks themselves support it, as Section VII shows. The Hijri dates are given in the tabular calendar and may differ by a day or two from dates fixed by sighting of the moon; the Vikrami new-year dates and solar days are calculated for Lahore and may differ by a day from a particular almanac.

Table 1  ·  The Vikrami years VS 1893–1907 in both lunar reckonings, with the Hijri years each one spans

VSKartik reckoning (used here)AHChaitra reckoningAHSolar year begins
189310 Nov 1836 – 29 Oct 18371252–125318 Mar 1836 – 5 Apr 18371251–125212 Apr 1836
189430 Oct 1837 – 18 Oct 18381253–12546 Apr 1837 – 25 Mar 18381252–125312 Apr 1837
189519 Oct 1838 – 6 Nov 18391254–125526 Mar 1838 – 15 Mar 18391253–125412 Apr 1838
18967 Nov 1839 – 25 Oct 18401255–125616 Mar 1839 – 2 Apr 18401254–125613 Apr 1839
189726 Oct 1840 – 13 Nov 18411256–12573 Apr 1840 – 23 Mar 18411256–125712 Apr 1840
189814 Nov 1841 – 2 Nov 18421257–125824 Mar 1841 – 10 Apr 18421257–125812 Apr 1841
18993 Nov 1842 – 23 Oct 18431258–125911 Apr 1842 – 30 Mar 18431258–125912 Apr 1842
190024 Oct 1843 – 10 Nov 18441259–126031 Mar 1843 – 18 Mar 18441259–126013 Apr 1843
190111 Nov 1844 – 30 Oct 18451260–126119 Mar 1844 – 6 Apr 18451260–126112 Apr 1844
190231 Oct 1845 – 20 Oct 18461261–12627 Apr 1845 – 27 Mar 18461261–126212 Apr 1845
190321 Oct 1846 – 8 Nov 18471262–126328 Mar 1846 – 16 Mar 18471262–126312 Apr 1846
19049 Nov 1847 – 27 Oct 18481263–126417 Mar 1847 – 3 Apr 18481263–126413 Apr 1847
190528 Oct 1848 – 16 Oct 18491264–12654 Apr 1848 – 24 Mar 18491264–126512 Apr 1848
190617 Oct 1849 – 4 Nov 18501265–126625 Mar 1849 – 13 Mar 18501265–126612 Apr 1849
19075 Nov 1850 – 24 Oct 18511266–126714 Mar 1850 – 1 Apr 18511266–126712 Apr 1850

Two consequences follow at once. Duleep Singh was proclaimed on 16 September 1843: in the Kartik reckoning that is VS 1899, in the Chaitra and solar reckonings VS 1900. And the annexation was proclaimed on 29 March 1849, four days after the Chaitra new year: it is VS 1906 in the Chaitra reckoning, but VS 1905 in the Kartik and solar reckonings. Longworth Dames in 1888 placed a Derajat rupee of VS 1906 "when the Khalsa army was making its last struggle against the British Government"; only the Chaitra reckoning could put any VS 1906 coin inside the Sikh state, and then only for four days.

III  ·  The Record

Herrli's Tables: Four Series at Once

The marks did not change one at a time. Herrli showed that from about VS 1858 the Amritsar Nanakshahi "splits into 3–4 parallel subseries differing in their marks", which "usually ran for a few years and then were replaced by new ones" until the mint closed in VS 1906. He compared them to the marks that identified different workshops within an Imperial Roman mint, and suggested that the Amritsar series "may point to the existence of more than one workshop within the Amritsar mint or to orders from more than one customer."

The rupees of these years carry the frozen date VS 1885 in the legend together with the actual year of striking, which Herrli writes as 1885/94, 1885/1903 and so on. His tables (types 01.11 and 01.12, pages 75–76) are summarised below. Herrli numbers the mark positions but not the parallel series; this page calls his four columns Series A to D, from left to right.

Table 2  ·  The obverse marks of the Amritsar Nanakshahi, VS 1893–1906, by parallel series (after Herrli 2004, pp. 75–76)

VSSeries ASeries BSeries CSeries D
1893—face—face; umbrella-like mark; fork-shaped reverse mark
1894—faces, flowerRam (Devnagri)umbrella-like mark, faces; fork-shaped reverse mark
1895——fish-like markface; fork-shaped reverse mark
1896——star of dotsOm (one form)
1897———Om (seven forms)
1898—R in a circleTrident (four forms)—
1899leafsun-like markTrident; trident beneath a canopyCanopy over a staff
1900–01——Canopy over a staffCanopy over a staff
1902flowers, one rose-likeFlag; canopy with flag——
1903Sat (alone); sun-faceCanopy over flagCanopy over SatCanopy over Sat, enclosed
1904——Canopy over Sat (six forms)Canopy over Sat, enclosed
1905Shivsmall canopy over a sprayCanopy over Sat; canopy over other letters, including Ram in LandeCanopy over Sat, enclosed
1906——Canopy over Ram in Lande—

The descriptions of pictorial marks are this page's; the letters are as Herrli prints them, and the reading of the last Series C letters as Ram in Lande script is this site's. Herrli prints Shiv (VS 1905) in Gurmukhi-like letters; the specimens in the archives are to be checked against his drawing. Herrli also warns that rupees dated VS 1900 and 1901 with a peacock in place of the canopy are recent fabrications. The rose on the reverse of the VS 1902 flag type, recorded from a specimen in these archives, is not in his table.

The register changes the question. A mark that appears in one series while the other series carry something else cannot be a statement made by the court on behalf of the whole mint; it belongs to the workshop, or the official, or the customer behind that series. A mark that appears in several series at once is a different matter. Two marks do this: the canopy, which begins in Series C and D in VS 1899 and by VS 1903 stands in three of the four, and Sat, which appears in Series A, C and D together in VS 1903. Every other mark is confined to one series.

IV  ·  Method

Three Ways to Read a Mark

Any single mark can be explained in at least three ways, and they are not exclusive.

A power-holder's signal. The mark announces who controls the court, or the mint. This is the reading the question invites, and the hardest to prove.

An official's mark. Indo-Persian mints commonly carried small marks that identified the issue, the mint-master or the contractor who farmed the mint. A Hindu official might set his own invocation on the dies of his series, with no reference to the court at all. Herrli's parallel series make this the default reading for any mark confined to one series.

A devotional or auspicious word. An invocation chosen for the year, with no personal reference.

Devotional formulae did go onto Lahore-state coins in exactly these years: the Nimak rupee of VS 1905 in this collection carries Sri Ramji Sahai, struck at Pind Dadan Khan under Misr Rallia (Rulia) Ram and his son Misr Sahib Dyal (see The Nimak Mint). They were Brahmins whose family had served the Kanhaiya misl, heads of the Darbar’s customs since 1812, placed in charge of the recoinage at the British Resident’s request in September 1847, and made Rajas by the British in 1851. Before 1846 the Salt Range mines had been farmed to Gulab Singh, but no source yet found ties these two officials to the Dogras. Their invocation is an official’s, chosen by men answerable to the Resident. What can lift a reading above the official's mark is timing — a mark that begins or ends with a change of ruler — and spread — a mark taken up by several series at once.

V  ·  The Evidence

The Marks, One by One

Dates are given in the Kartik reckoning; Section VII reads every mark again in the Chaitra reckoning. The plates are specimens from the SikhCoins.in archives.

Plate 1images/amritsar-marks-01.webp
Plate 1 · Ram in Devnagri, Amritsar rupee, VS 1894 · SikhCoins.in archives

Ram  ·  Devnagri  ·  VS 1894  ·  Series C

30 Oct 1837 – 18 Oct 1838  ·  AH 1253–1254  ·  Ranjit Singh alive

Open

Rama was the family deity of the Jammu Dogras; Gulab Singh founded the Raghunath temple at Jammu in about 1835, and his brother Dhian Singh, wazir since 1828, controlled access to the Maharaja. A Ram mark in 1837–38 would fit the Dogra circle at the height of its influence.

But Herrli's table shows Ram in one series only, while the other series of the same year carried faces, flowers and an umbrella-like mark. A court signal would not be confined to one workshop. The mark falls within Ranjit Singh's lifetime in any reckoning, and an official's invocation is the simpler reading.

Plate 2images/amritsar-marks-02.webp
Plate 2 · Om in Devnagri, Amritsar rupee, VS 1897 · SikhCoins.in archives

Om  ·  Devnagri  ·  VS 1896 – 1897  ·  Series D

7 Nov 1839 – 13 Nov 1841  ·  AH 1255–1257  ·  Kharak Singh, Chand Kaur, Sher Singh

Open

Herrli records one Om form already in VS 1896 and seven in VS 1897, all in Series D. VS 1896 began on 7 November 1839, in Kharak Singh's reign, so Om begins under Kharak Singh and Nau Nihal Singh, not with Sher Singh. Om is the Pranava, common to every Hindu tradition; confined to one series and beginning before any change of ruler, it is best read as an invocation.

Plate 3images/amritsar-marks-03.webp
Plate 3 · Trident (trishul), Amritsar rupee, VS 1898–1899 · SikhCoins.in archives

Trishul  ·  VS 1898 – 1899  ·  Series C

14 Nov 1841 – 23 Oct 1843  ·  AH 1257–1259  ·  Sher Singh

Argued

The trident is the emblem of Shiva, and its run as an obverse mark coincides with Sher Singh's reign. Sher Singh was Kanhaiya on his mother's side — his mother Mehtab Kaur was the daughter of Sada Kaur — and was raised in Batala, Kanhaiya country, where he withdrew again in December 1840. Near Batala stands Achaleshwar, an old Shaivite shrine associated with Kartikeya, the son of Shiva, and Sher Singh is reported locally to have made gifts to it.

Two cautions. The trident is in one series only. And fork-shaped marks already appear on the reverse of Series D in VS 1893–95, in Ranjit Singh's lifetime. The obverse trident is new in VS 1898, and if Sher Singh's patronage of Achaleshwar can be documented, it becomes the clearest personal mark in the run. See Sher Singh.

Plate 4images/amritsar-marks-04.webp
Plate 4 · Royal canopy (chattra), Amritsar rupee, VS 1899–1901 · SikhCoins.in archives

Chattra  ·  from VS 1899  ·  Series C and D, then all four

16 Sep 1843 onwards  ·  AH 1259 onwards  ·  Duleep Singh; Hira Singh, then Jawahir Singh

Argued  ·  the strongest reading

The chattra is the canopy held over a ruler: in Indian iconography, sovereignty itself. Herrli's table shows exactly how it arrived. In VS 1899 Series C was striking Sher Singh's trident; among its last dies is a trident beneath a canopy. The canopy was set over the trident, and then the trident gave way to a plain staff. In the Kartik reckoning VS 1899 ends on 23 October 1843, so the change falls in the five weeks after Sher Singh's murder and Duleep Singh's proclamation on 16 September.

A canopy over a child on the throne is a natural emblem of regency — the throne's authority, exercised by others in the minor's name — first under Jind Kaur and the wazirs, later under the Council of Regency. An umbrella-like mark had appeared in Series D in VS 1893–94 and lapsed; this canopy did not. It is also the one mark that spread: from two series in VS 1899–1901 to three by VS 1903. It survives every change of wazir, the war, the treaties of 1846 and the Resident. It marks the office, not the person who held it.

Plate 5images/amritsar-marks-05.webp
Plate 5 · Flag below the chattra, Amritsar rupee, VS 1902–1903 · SikhCoins.in archives

Flag below Chattra  ·  VS 1902 – 1903  ·  Series B

31 Oct 1845 – 8 Nov 1847  ·  AH 1261–1263  ·  the war, the treaties, Bhairowal

Open

From 1845 the Khalsa army, governed by its own panchayats, was the decisive power at Lahore: it made and unmade wazirs, and it marched to the Sutlej. A flag beneath the canopy reads naturally as the army acting under the throne. But the flag is confined to Series B, which in a mint of parallel workshops makes it one series' mark rather than the mint's.

Plate 6images/amritsar-marks-06.webp
Plate 6 · Rose (gulab) on the reverse, flag type, Amritsar rupee, VS 1902 · SikhCoins.in archives

Gulab on the reverse  ·  VS 1902 subtype

31 Oct 1845 – 20 Oct 1846  ·  AH 1261–1262  ·  Gulab Singh wazir from 31 Jan 1846

Open

A rose is gulab, and from 31 January 1846 Raja Gulab Singh stood at the centre of Lahore politics: wazir in place of Lal Singh, negotiator with the British, and from 16 March ruler of Jammu and Kashmir by the Treaty of Amritsar. A visual pun on a noble's name would suit the habits of a Persianate court.

Against it: in the same year Herrli's Series A carried several flowers, one of them rose-like, on the obverse, and floral sprays are a stock ornament on Sikh reverses. The test is distribution: if the rose subtype is scarce and its dies sit in the middle of VS 1902, the pun gains weight; if roses are common through the year, it should be set aside.

Plate 7images/amritsar-marks-07.webp
Plate 7 · Sat in Gurmukhi below the chattra, Amritsar rupee, VS 1903–1905 · SikhCoins.in archives

Sat  ·  Gurmukhi, below Chattra  ·  VS 1903 – 1905  ·  Series A, C and D

21 Oct 1846 – 16 Oct 1849  ·  AH 1262–1265  ·  the Council of Regency under the Resident

Argued

VS 1903 opened on 21 October 1846. Within eight weeks Lal Singh had been deposed and the Treaty of Bhairowal had placed the state under a Council of Regency whose every payment bore the British Resident's countersignature; in August 1847 Jind Kaur was removed from Lahore. In VS 1903 the Gurmukhi word Sat — the Khalsa's own word, in the Khalsa's own script — appears in three of the four series at once: alone in Series A, beneath the canopy in Series C and D. After the canopy, it is the only mark the mint adopted across its workshops. It reads as a statement of identity under a regency the Khalsa no longer controlled.

Plate 8images/amritsar-marks-08.webp
Plate 8 · Ram in Lande script below the chattra, Amritsar rupee, VS 1905 · SikhCoins.in archives

Ram  ·  Lande, below Chattra  ·  VS 1905  ·  Series C

28 Oct 1848 – 16 Oct 1849  ·  AH 1264–1265  ·  second war; annexation

Open

Lande was the mercantile script of Khatri and Arora traders and accountants, strongest in the western Punjab and Multan. Its appearance on the Amritsar dies points to the people who kept the mint's books rather than to the court. It is confined to Series C, where the canopy over Sat continued alongside it, and it outlives the Sikh state (plate 11).

Plate 9images/amritsar-marks-09.webp
Plate 9 · Shiv, Amritsar rupee, VS 1905 · SikhCoins.in archives

Shiv  ·  VS 1905  ·  Series A

28 Oct 1848 – 16 Oct 1849  ·  AH 1264–1265

Open

A second Shaivite mark, five years after Sher Singh's death, in the series that had carried Sat alone in VS 1903. Herrli prints it in Gurmukhi-like letters. Confined to one series, it is better read as an official's devotion than as a court signal.

Plate 10images/amritsar-marks-10.webp
Plate 10 · Shiv with Ram in Lande, Amritsar rupee, VS 1905 · SikhCoins.in archives

Shiv and Ram together  ·  VS 1905

28 Oct 1848 – 16 Oct 1849

Open

Two scripts and two invocations on one die, in one year — a combination recorded from a specimen in these archives and not in Herrli's table. Political signals are not usually mixed this way; officials' marks often are. It is the best evidence that the VS 1905 marks belong to the mint's own staff.

Plate 11images/amritsar-marks-11.webp
Plate 11 · Ram in Lande script below the chattra, Amritsar rupee, VS 1906 · SikhCoins.in archives

Ram  ·  Lande, below Chattra  ·  VS 1906  ·  Series C

17 Oct 1849 – 4 Nov 1850  ·  AH 1265–1266  ·  after the annexation

Argued

In the Kartik reckoning VS 1906 began on 17 October 1849, more than six months after the annexation; in the Chaitra reckoning it began on 25 March 1849, four days before it. Either way the chattra here cannot be a living claim of Sikh sovereignty. Herrli dates the closing of the Amritsar mint to VS 1906, and this is the last year in his table: one series, carrying its own mark on, to the end. That continuity is the strongest reason to read the Lande Ram as an official's mark rather than a regime's.

VI  ·  Events

The Years of the Marks: Events in Three Eras

The table below gives the principal events at Lahore in the years of the marks, dated in the Common Era, in the Punjab solar Vikrami reckoning used in civil records, in both lunar Vikrami reckonings, and in the Hijri era. It has been checked against the chronology in Appendix D of Surinder Singh's Sikh Coinage: Symbol of Sikh Sovereignty, and every point at which the two differ is noted.

One difference is systematic. Surinder Singh's table numbers each Vikrami year from 1 January — VS = AD + 57 for the whole calendar year. That is correct from April to December, but not from January to March, when no reckoning had yet reached the next Vikrami year. His table therefore places Aliwal, Sobraon and both treaties of 1846 in VS 1903, and Chillianwala, Multan's surrender and Gujrat in VS 1906. In every reckoning these fall a year earlier, in VS 1902 and VS 1905. Only for events in the last days of March, after the Chaitra new year but before Vaisakhi — Suchet Singh's death in 1844 and the annexation in 1849 — is his number right, and then only in the Chaitra reckoning.

Table 3  ·  Principal events, VS 1894–1905, in the Common, Vikrami and Hijri eras

CEVS solar dateVS year: Kartik / ChaitraAHEventNote on Surinder Singh, App. D
30 Apr 183720 Vaisakh 18941893 / 189424 Muharram 1253Hari Singh Nalwa dies of wounds after the battle of Jamrud—
6 Sep 183824 Bhadon 18951894 / 189516 Jumada II 1254Duleep Singh bornListed by Surinder Singh under 1838 without a day.
27 Jun 183915 Harh 18961895 / 189614 Rabi II 1255Ranjit Singh dies at LahoreTraditional record: 15 Harh 1896 — matches the computed date.
1 Sep 183918 Bhadon 18961895 / 189621 Jumada II 1255Kharak Singh installed as Maharaja; Dhian Singh wazir—
9 Oct 183925 Assu 18961895 / 189630 Rajab 1255Chet Singh Bajwa, Kharak Singh's adviser, killed in the palaceUndated in Surinder Singh.
5 Nov 184023 Katak 1897189710 Ramadan 1256Kharak Singh dies; Nau Nihal Singh mortally injured at the gateway returning from the cremation, and dies that night—
18 Jan 18418 Magh 1897189725 Dhu al-Qada 1256Sher Singh takes Lahore and is proclaimed Maharaja; Chand Kaur's regency endsNumbered VS 1898: the Vikrami year had not yet turned. Surinder Singh: occupied the fort 20 Jan 1841.
11 Jun 184231 Jeth 18991898 / 18992 Jumada I 1258Chand Kaur killedSurinder Singh: June 1842.
15 Sep 18431 Assu 19001899 / 190020 Shaban 1259Sher Singh, his son Partap Singh and Dhian Singh killed by the Sandhanwalias—
16 Sep 18432 Assu 19001899 / 190021 Shaban 1259Duleep Singh, aged five, proclaimed Maharaja, with Jind Kaur as regent—
17 Sep 18433 Assu 19001899 / 190022 Shaban 1259Hira Singh, Dhian Singh's son, becomes wazir—
27 Mar 184416 Chet 19001900 / 19017 Rabi I 1260Suchet Singh killed near LahoreNumbered VS 1901: correct only in the Chaitra reckoning, whose year had just turned; the solar year had not. Surinder Singh: Mar 1844.
21 Dec 18449 Poh 1901190110 Dhu al-Hijja 1260Hira Singh killed in flight towards Jammu; Jawahir Singh risesSurinder Singh gives 12 Dec 1844 for the flight; the killing is 21 Dec.
14 May 18453 Jeth 19021901 / 19027 Jumada I 1261Jawahir Singh, Jind Kaur's brother, formally made wazirSurinder Singh dates his regency council to 28 Dec 1844.
21 Sep 18458 Assu 19021901 / 190219 Ramadan 1261Jawahir Singh executed by the army panchayatsSurinder Singh: Sept 1845.
8 Nov 184525 Katak 190219028 Dhu al-Qada 1261Lal Singh wazir, Tej Singh commander-in-chiefSurinder Singh: Nov 1845.
11 Dec 184528 Maghar 1902190211 Dhu al-Hijja 1261The Khalsa army begins crossing the SutlejSurinder Singh gives 23 Nov 1845 for the march to the ferries.
18 Dec 18456 Poh 1902190218 Dhu al-Hijja 1261Battle of Mudki—
21 Dec 18459 Poh 1902190221 Dhu al-Hijja 1261Battle of Ferozeshah (21–22 Dec)Surinder Singh calls it the battle of Ferozepur; it was fought at Ferozeshah.
28 Jan 184617 Magh 1902190230 Muharram 1262Battle of AliwalNumbered VS 1903: the Vikrami year had not yet turned. Surinder Singh calls Aliwal a minor skirmish; it was a decisive British victory.
31 Jan 184620 Magh 190219023 Safar 1262Gulab Singh replaces Lal Singh as wazir and opens terms with the BritishNumbered VS 1903: the Vikrami year had not yet turned.
10 Feb 18461 Phagan 1902190213 Safar 1262Battle of SobraonNumbered VS 1903: the Vikrami year had not yet turned.
9 Mar 184628 Phagan 1902190211 Rabi I 1262Treaty of LahoreNumbered VS 1903: the Vikrami year had not yet turned.
16 Mar 18465 Chet 1902190218 Rabi I 1262Treaty of Amritsar: Jammu and Kashmir to Gulab Singh for 75 lakh rupeesNumbered VS 1903: the Vikrami year had not yet turned. Surinder Singh: 'treaty at Ambala … for Rs 1 crore'. It was signed at Amritsar; Gulab Singh paid 75 lakh.
Dec 1846Maghar 19031903Dhu al-Hijja 1262Lal Singh tried for the Kashmir resistance, deposed and exiledSurinder Singh places his removal just after the Treaty of Amritsar (Mar 1846); the inquiry and deposition were in December 1846.
16 Dec 18464 Poh 1903190327 Dhu al-Hijja 1262Treaty of Bhairowal: Council of Regency under the British Resident—
Aug 1847Bhadon 19041903 / 1904Ramadan 1263Jind Kaur removed from Lahore to SheikhupuraSources differ between August and September 1847.
20 Apr 184810 Vaisakh 19051904 / 190516 Jumada I 1264Vans Agnew and Anderson killed at Multan; Mulraj's rising beginsSurinder Singh: Mar 1848.
22 Nov 184810 Maghar 1905190525 Dhu al-Hijja 1264Battle of Ramnagar—
13 Jan 18493 Magh 1905190518 Safar 1265Battle of ChillianwalaNumbered VS 1906: the Vikrami year had not yet turned.
22 Jan 184912 Magh 1905190527 Safar 1265Multan surrendersNumbered VS 1906: the Vikrami year had not yet turned.
21 Feb 184912 Phagan 1905190528 Rabi I 1265Battle of GujratNumbered VS 1906: the Vikrami year had not yet turned. Surinder Singh: 12 Mar 1849, which is the surrender, not the battle.
14 Mar 18493 Chet 1905190519 Rabi II 1265Sikh army surrenders near RawalpindiNumbered VS 1906: the Vikrami year had not yet turned.
29 Mar 184918 Chet 19051905 / 19065 Jumada I 1265Annexation of the Punjab proclaimed at LahoreNumbered VS 1906: correct only in the Chaitra reckoning, whose year had just turned; the solar year had not.

Solar dates are counted from the day on which the sun enters each sign, at Lahore; Hijri dates are in the tabular calendar. Either may differ by a day from a particular almanac or record. Dates shown by month only are those on which the sources disagree.

VII  ·  Comparative Study

The Marks Under Both Reckonings

Section V reads the marks in the Kartik reckoning. The test of that choice is to read every mark again in the Chaitra reckoning and ask which reading survives. A reckoning that makes the marks fall cleanly on changes of power is to be preferred; one that makes them fall in the middle of reigns weakens the case for court influence altogether.

Mark & VSKartik reckoningChaitra reckoningBetter fit
Ram
1894
30 Oct 1837 – 18 Oct 1838. Ranjit Singh; Dhian Singh wazir.6 Apr 1837 – 25 Mar 1838. The same.Neither
Om
1896–97
7 Nov 1839 – 13 Nov 1841. Begins under Kharak Singh.16 Mar 1839 – 23 Mar 1841. Begins in Ranjit Singh's last months.Neither: before Sher Singh either way
Trishul
1898–99
14 Nov 1841 – 23 Oct 1843. Sher Singh to 15 Sep 1843, then five weeks of Duleep Singh.24 Mar 1841 – 30 Mar 1843. Wholly within Sher Singh's reign.Both fit
Chattra
from 1899
VS 1899 ends 23 Oct 1843: the canopy over the trident can mark Duleep Singh's proclamation on 16 Sep.VS 1899 ends 30 Mar 1843: the canopy begins under Sher Singh, an adult king, at least six months before Duleep's accession.Kartik
Flag below Chattra
1902–03
31 Oct 1845 – 8 Nov 1847. Opens as the army marches to the Sutlej; runs on after the army's reduction under the Treaty of Lahore.7 Apr 1845 – 16 Mar 1847. Opens at the height of the army panchayats' power — the year they killed Jawahir Singh and forced the war.Chaitra
Gulab (reverse)
1902
31 Oct 1845 – 20 Oct 1846. Gulab Singh wazir from 31 Jan 1846, mid-year.7 Apr 1845 – 27 Mar 1846. Gulab Singh pressed by the army early in the year; wazir in its last two months.Both fit
Sat below Chattra
1903–05
21 Oct 1846 – 16 Oct 1849. Opens eight weeks before Bhairowal.28 Mar 1846 – 24 Mar 1849. Opens with the Treaty of Amritsar's aftermath; ends five days before the annexation.Both fit
Ram (Lande), Shiv
1905
28 Oct 1848 – 16 Oct 1849. Mid-war to six months after annexation.4 Apr 1848 – 24 Mar 1849. Wholly within the Sikh state; Mulraj's rising begins 20 Apr 1848.Chaitra, weakly
Ram (Lande) below Chattra
1906
17 Oct 1849 – 4 Nov 1850. Wholly after annexation.25 Mar 1849 – 13 Mar 1850. Begins four days before the annexation.Neither: post-Sikh both ways

What the Kartik reckoning gains. The chattra. In Herrli's Series C the canopy is first set over the trident within VS 1899. In the Kartik reckoning that year reaches 23 October 1843, and the canopy can mark the passage from Sher Singh to Duleep Singh; in the Chaitra reckoning VS 1899 ended in March 1843, and the canopy would be Sher Singh's own.

What the Chaitra reckoning gains. The flag fits the army better: in Chaitra years its first year is the year the army panchayats ruled Lahore outright. The Lande Ram of VS 1905 also falls wholly within the Sikh state, though nothing else ties it to Mulraj.

What neither changes. Ram and Om both begin before Sher Singh in either reckoning. The trident is Sher Singh's either way. The rose falls in a year of Gulab Singh's prominence either way. Sat is the mark of the defeated state either way. And VS 1906 is post-Sikh either way.

The balance. The Kartik reckoning wins the chattra, which is the sharpest discriminator, because it is the one mark whose meaning turns on a single month and the one taken up across the mint. The Chaitra reckoning wins the flag, a single-series mark that fits the army in both reckonings and only fits it better in one. On this count the Kartik reckoning remains the better working convention.

A test that could decide it: in the Kartik reckoning, the VS 1899 canopy in Series C was struck for about five weeks (16 September – 23 October 1843), against more than ten months of the VS 1899 trident (3 November 1842 – 15 September 1843). VS 1899 canopy pieces should therefore be markedly scarcer than VS 1899 trident pieces. In the Chaitra reckoning there is no reason for them to be.

VIII  ·  The Pattern

The Canopy and What Stands Beneath It

Taken together, the marks fall into two layers. Before September 1843 each series carried its own marks, and none of them spread: Ram, Om and the trident each belong to a single workshop, though the trident's years are Sher Singh's. From Duleep Singh's proclamation the chattra was set over the trident and then spread across the mint — the throne, held in a child's name — and a second mark beneath it varied: the flag in one series, the Khalsa's Sat in three, and at the end the private invocations of the mint's own officials.

MarkVSSeriesMost likely referenceGrade
Ram (Devnagri)1894CAn official's invocation; possibly the Dogra circleOpen
Om1896–97DAn invocationOpen
Trishul1898–99CSher Singh; Batala and AchaleshwarArgued
Chattra1899–1906C, D, then BThe throne in regency for Duleep SinghArgued — strongest
Flag below Chattra1902–03BThe Khalsa army, or one series' emblemOpen
Gulab (reverse)1902—Gulab Singh, or ornamentOpen
Sat below Chattra1903–05A, C, DKhalsa identity under the Council of RegencyArgued
Ram (Lande), Shiv1905–06C; AMint officialsOpen / Argued

The honest conclusion is narrower than the question. The chattra and Sat are the only marks the mint took up across its workshops, and both change at points of political change; they are the best candidates for statements of sovereignty and identity. The trident is the best candidate for a personal mark. The rest are most economically read as the invocations of the people who ran each series.

IX  ·  Open Questions

What Would Settle It

The Amritsar mint's officials. Names of the mint-master, contractors or workshop heads year by year, if they can be recovered, would test the official's-mark reading directly — and might explain Herrli's parallel series.

Die links. Do the last trident dies and the first canopy dies of Series C share a reverse? If the canopy-over-trident die can be fixed to the autumn of 1843, the regency reading is close to proved.

The form of the chattra. Whether the canopy's tiers, tassels or position change between VS 1899 and VS 1900, or again after 1846, would show whether its meaning was fixed or revised.

The other mints. If Lahore, Multan and the frontier mints carry no comparable marks in the same years, the marks are an Amritsar practice, and point to the management of that mint.

The rose. A count of the VS 1902 rose subtype against the plain flag type, and its die links.

Achaleshwar. A sanad, gazetteer entry or temple record of Sher Singh's patronage.

The year's turn. A coin or document carrying both a VS year and a datable event would fix the Kartik or Chaitra question for the Amritsar mint. Short of that, the relative scarcity of VS 1899 canopy and VS 1899 trident pieces (Section VII) is the best test available from the coins alone.

Notes on Sources

  • Hans Herrli, The Coins of the Sikhs, 2nd ed. (Munshiram Manoharlal, 2004): p. 22 (parallel subseries from about VS 1858; closing of the Amritsar mint in VS 1906); pp. 67–68 (the mark positions and their probable meaning); pp. 75–76 (types 01.11 and 01.12, marks for VS 1885/93 to 1885/1906, with notes 16–18). The series letters A–D and the descriptions of pictorial marks in Table 2 are this page's.
  • Surinder Singh, Sikh Coinage: Symbol of Sikh Sovereignty, Appendix D, chronology of events (pp. 254–259 for 1837–1850). The differences noted in Table 3 are this page's.
  • Vikrami new-year dates (Chaitra and Kartik), solar month beginnings and solar dates were calculated for Lahore from the positions of the sun and moon, using the Lahiri ayanamsa. The method reproduces the recorded date of Ranjit Singh's death, 15 Harh 1896. Hijri dates are in the tabular (arithmetical) Islamic calendar.
  • Event dates not taken from Surinder Singh: Chet Singh Bajwa's killing, 9 Oct 1839; Chand Kaur's death, 11 Jun 1842; Suchet Singh's death, 27 Mar 1844; Hira Singh's appointment, 17 Sep 1843, and death, 21 Dec 1844 (Encyclopaedia of Sikhism, Punjabi University); Jawahir Singh's appointment, 14 May 1845, and death, 21 Sep 1845; Lal Singh's appointment, 8 Nov 1845, and replacement by Gulab Singh, 31 Jan 1846.
  • Longworth Dames, "Coins of the Durranis and Barakzais," Numismatic Chronicle (1888), p. 330.
  • The Raghunath temple at Jammu, whose presiding deity is Rama, was begun under Gulab Singh in about 1835 and completed by his son Ranbir Singh. Achaleshwar near Batala is described by the Gurdaspur district administration as an ancient shrine associated with Kartikeya, son of Shiva; Sher Singh's patronage is reported locally, and a documentary source has not yet been found.
  • The Nimak rupee of VS 1905 with Sri Ramji Sahai (read on this site as Śāradā script; Herrli, p. 108, as probably Nagari), the VS 1902 rose-reverse subtype and the VS 1905 Shiv-and-Ram piece are recorded from specimens in the SikhCoins.in archives.
  • On Misr Rallia Ram and Misr Sahib Dyal: Lahore Political Diaries, p. 300 (27 Sep 1847); Edwardes's diary, 11 Jan 1848; Fleming, RASB 1849; Herrli, pp. 108–109, notes 2 and 8; Rajinder Kaur, Role of Select Courtiers and Officials at Lahore Darbar, 1799–1849 (thesis), after Griffin, The Punjab Chiefs.